Joseph Smith Was My 11th Guru: A Sikh’s Journey to the Restored Gospel (with James Goldberg)
James Goldberg grew up in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, surrounded by the Jewish and Sikh traditions of his extended family. His grandfather, Gurcharan Singh Gill, was the first known Sikh to join the Church, and James became an award-winning author, poet, playwright, and writer for the Church History Department. But the season that taught him the most about Jesus Christ began at 33, when a tumor found during surgery led to eight cycles of chemotherapy and two bone marrow stem cell transplants. His youngest child had just been born.
In this episode of Why We Believe, James shares why his grandfather took off his shoes to hear a prophet speak, how a stolen U-Haul and a ward basement in Ohio shaped his own faith, and what he learned in the former East Germany, where people who said they did not believe in God told him about guardian angels. He shares the verse about silver that came to him during chemotherapy, the faith he wants when he is drowning, and why he believes because he loves the many tastes of the restored gospel. Through these seasons, James testifies that Jesus Christ is near when pain feels unbearable.
Loved this episode? Hit Follow and share it with someone who needs a reminder that Jesus Christ is near in the hardest hours. Leave a review for Why We Believe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube. Your support helps us bring more inspiring conversations like this to listeners everywhere!
Visit WhyWeBelieve.com to download Your FREE guide on 13 Strategies to Increase Faith in Jesus Christ, to support you as you strengthen your own testimony of Jesus Christ. Follow the Why We Believe Show Follow Nathan Gwilliam
WhyWeBelieve.com | YouTube: @WhyWeBelieveShow | LinkedIn: @Why-We-Believe-Show | Instagram: @WhyWeBelievePodcast
LinkedIn: @NathanGwilliam | Website: PodUp.com | Podcasts - Why We Believe: WhyWeBelieve.com | Podcasting Secrets: PodcastingSecrets.com
Website: goldbergish.com | Substack: @jamesgoldberg | Patreon: @jamesgoldberg
A Sikh Grandfather Took Off His Shoes. His Grandson Reached for Christ's Hands.
The stake missionaries took a young Sikh convert to hear President McKay speak, and he took off his shoes. Others told him he did not have to. He answered that he did. Where he came from, that was how you honored a holy place and a holy moment, and he felt he was standing in one.
That man was Gurcharan Singh Gill, the first known Sikh to join The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and his grandson carries the story forward. On a recent episode of Why We Believe, host Nathan Gwilliam sat down with James Goldberg, a writer for the Church History Department and coauthor of Latter-day Sikh. Their conversation covers a grandfather's grief, a mission in East Germany, and a season of chemotherapy that taught James where to reach when he was drowning.
A Question About a Sister
Gurcharan was born in 1935 in Punjab, under British rule, one of ten children on a farm. His older sister trained him to become a schoolteacher, and he dreamed of studying in America. Then she and his baby brother fell sick. He was with her when she died, after they could not get into a hospital that had closed for the night. Within a month, his baby brother was gone too.
He came to the United States and picked peaches to work his way through college, carrying a question he could not set down. He could not shake the feeling that his sister was still out there somewhere as herself. In the 1950s, the answers he heard left little hope for a sister who was not a Christian. Then a friend's mother, active in her Pentecostal church, told him to talk to the Latter-day Saints.
A friend invited him to a stake conference where the theme happened to be the plan of salvation. James says it just hit him. Gurcharan read the scriptures and Jesus the Christ, joined the Church, and was able to do ordinances for himself and, ultimately, for his sister, finding the reconciliation he had been looking for.
A Stolen U-Haul and a Ward Basement
James grew up with a mother of deep devotion, visits to the Sikh Gurdwara, and Hanukkah candles lit by his father, whose own father was Jewish. Those traditions gave him a religious sense of wonder. His father, shaped by the early internet and its competing voices about Church history, struggled with the Church through James's adolescence, and when James wanted to serve a mission, he said he would rather see him join the military. James went anyway. He says his father has softened since.
At 12, James moved to Ohio. Their U-Haul was stolen with their belongings inside, and they could not close on their house, so the family lived in a ward member's basement and wore clothes the ward handed them. That was how he came to know the Church up close. He learned to see Church history as a laboratory where imperfect people test discipleship, and he chose the Church the way you choose a life in full color, heights and depths included.
Guardian Angels in East Germany
James served in the Leipzig mission, combined with Berlin, and covering the former East Germany a decade after the wall fell. About ninety percent of the people he met were officially atheists. On the street, he would ask whether they believed in God, and they would say no. Then he would ask whether they had wondered what it would feel like. Several times the answer became a story about a guardian angel they could not otherwise explain. Two people learned to pray after seeing a prayer once on television.
One woman held a common objection, asking why children die if there is a God. The missionaries did not settle it for her. The Book of Mormon did, through Jacob's parable of the olive vineyard, where the Lord of the vineyard tends the trees. She had done some gardening, and the parable made sense to her. God taught her that He is there and working with people, and she was baptized. James says the bigger barrier in that land was a lack of trust in people more than a lack of belief in God.
Reaching for Christ's Hands
James was 33 when he woke from what he thought was gallbladder surgery and heard the words pancreatic cancer. Surgeons had found a tumor between his pancreas and his liver. It was his second fight with cancer. News that it was a recurrence in an unusual place brought a celebration because the odds were better. The treatment still resisted him, and it meant almost a year of chemotherapy and two bone marrow stem cell transplants.
In that first moment, his comfort looked backward. He told his wife he felt good about the life he had lived. Later, burning with fever, he told the Lord it was too much. If you bake a cake, he reasoned, you do it at 350. Then a verse came to mind about being refined as silver, and he realized he was not a cake. He told the Lord they were going to do this.
In a Catholic hospital room, a crucifix on the wall helped him understand in a new way what it means for Christ to suffer with us, and what felt unbearable became more bearable. Peter became his pattern. James does not ask only for the faith to walk on water. He wants the faith to reach for Christ's hands when he is drowning. Sorrow, he says, works like a centrifugal force that drives us toward each other, and heaven is sociality exalted.
The Many Tastes of the Restored Gospel
A job on the Joseph Smith Papers let James watch a new church take shape in the documents, and he recognized the human dynamics he had seen in his own theater company. He says the work helped him feel he knew Brother Joseph better. A bishop once asked him to teach Jesus in an hour, and the lesson grew into The Five Books of Jesus, a novel that retells the gospels through the eyes of the people around Christ. He calls writing it a devotional experience.
Asked why he believes, James answers that he loves the many tastes of the restored gospel. He says habit can blind us to what is familiar, so he looks again with fresh eyes, sometimes through another culture, like the Punjabi saying that a guest is like God. He has watched members of an Alzheimer's ward straighten when the sacrament prayers are spoken. When faith feels flat, he suggests digging deeper, talking to someone else, and looking at the gospel from another angle until you can taste again. Nathan pointed to Alma 32, where the word is compared to a seed that grows until it becomes delicious.
Key Takeaways
James' witness offers a pattern we can follow. Faith is not only walking on water. It is reaching for Christ's hands when we are drowning. Jesus Christ knows our pain from within, and the unbearable can become more bearable with Him near. The restored gospel answers the questions love asks, including what becomes of those we have lost. Trials do more than strengthen us. They draw us toward God and toward one another in love. And faith grows when we look at the restored gospel with fresh eyes until it becomes delicious again.
If James's story stirred something in you, listen to the full conversation on Why We Believe and reach for Christ in your own hardest hour.
Visit WhyWeBelieve.com to download Your FREE guide on 13 Strategies to Increase Faith in Jesus Christ, to support you as you strengthen your own testimony of Jesus Christ.
Thank you for reading this week's blog post inspired by the Why We Believe show. If you are interested in more stories like this, you can check out our other blog posts and episodes at WhyWeBelieve.com, or listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.
Follow the Why We Believe Show
WhyWeBelieve.com | YouTube: @WhyWeBelieveShow | LinkedIn: @Why-We-Believe-Show | Instagram: @WhyWeBelievePodcast
Follow Nathan Gwilliam
LinkedIn: @NathanGwilliam | Website: PodUp.com | Podcasts - Why We Believe: WhyWeBelieve.com | Podcasting Secrets: PodcastingSecrets.com
Follow James Goldberg
Website: goldbergish.com | Substack: @jamesgoldberg | Patreon: @jamesgoldberg
